LWV League of Women Voters of California
Smart Voter
Santa Clara County, CA March 5, 2002 Election
Measure E
Construction and Repair of Facilities
West Valley-Mission Joint Community College District

Bond Issue; 55% approval required

30,824 / 50.4% Yes votes ...... 30,327 / 49.6% No votes

See Also: Index of all Measures

Information shown below: Yes/No Meaning | Impartial Analysis | Arguments | Tax Rate Statement | Full Text

To improve educational opportunities for local residents, shall the West Valley-Mission Community College District issue $268,653,300 in bonds at legal interest rates to construct, acquire, repair and equip classrooms, libraries, science/computer labs, facilities/sites, upgrade technology, improve safety conditions and accessibility for the disabled, upgrade fire, earthquake safety, lighting, electrical, energy conservation, ventilation/plumbing systems, appoint a Citizen's Oversight Committee to perform annual audits and ensure that no bond money is used for salaries or administrative expenses?

Meaning of Voting Yes/No
A YES vote of this measure means:
A "yes" vote is a vote to authorize the issuance and sale of the general obligation bonds not to exceed the principal amount of $268,653,300 for the uses specified.

A NO vote of this measure means:
A "no" vote is a vote not to authorize the issuance and sale of said bonds.

Impartial Analysis from the County Counsel
The Board of Trustees of the West Valley-Mission Community College District has ordered an election on whether bonds shall be issued and sold in the aggregate principal amount not to exceed $268,653,300 to construct, acquire, repair and equip classrooms, libraries, improve the safety of college facilities.

Proposition 39, approved by the voters in a statewide election November, 2000, amended the California Constitution to authorize the issuance of bonded indebtedness to acquire or improve real property, if approved by fifty-five percent of the votes cast by voters in an election. The Constitution permits the debt service on such bonds to be paid through the imposition of ad valorem property taxes on property located within the district. The maturity of any such bonds issued would not exceed 25 years pursuant to the Election Code, and 40 years pursuant to the Government Code, at a rate of interest within the legal limit. Since the interest rate on the bonds is determined when the bonds are sold, the exact amount of the tax increase can only be determined after the bonds are sold.

With annual audits and citizen oversight, proceeds of the bonds would be used to upgrade classrooms and technology infrastructure at Mission College and West Valley College as described in the ballot statement. Projects include expansion of science laboratories, construction of new classrooms, and replacement of deteriorating athletic facilities.

A "yes" vote is a vote to authorize the issuance and sale of the general obligation bonds not to exceed the principal amount of $268,653,300 for the uses specified.

A "no" vote is a vote not to authorize the issuance and sale of said bonds.

Ann Miller Ravel, County Counsel

/s/ by Kathryn A. Berry, Deputy County Counsel

  Official Information

West Valley College

Please note
The material about this Measure has been retyped from Registrar of Voters' material. There could be errors. The official material can be obtained from the Registrar of Voters.
Events

Pros & Cons meeting
Feb. 21 - 7:30 - 9:30 pm
Saratoga Community Center
19655 Allendale Ave.
sponsored by AAUW and LWV
News and Analysis

Cupertino Courier

Los Gatos Weekly Times San Jose Metro Saratoga News Partisan Information

Supports

Opposes
Suggest a link related to Measure E
Links to sources outside of Smart Voter are provided for information only and do not imply endorsement.

Arguments For Measure E Arguments Against Measure E
Over the past four decades more than one million students from the Santa Clara Valley have benefited from the outstanding educational opportunities offered by West Valley-Mission Community College District, including West Valley College and Mission College.

Unfortunately, aging facilities negatively impact the quality of education, job training, career advancement and on-going instruction for thousands of local college students.

Facilities designed in the 1960's and 70's to meet higher education needs are inadequate today. Outdated classrooms as well as science and computer labs need renovating. Safety and seismic upgrades are needed. Aging energy, electrical, plumbing and heating systems need attention and are costly to operate. Repairs and renovations are needed now to provide up-to-date classrooms, job training and educational facilities.

Measure E will rehabilitate deteriorated educational facilities and add classrooms and instructional support space to properly serve our community. Measure E will:

  • Repair campus buildings to meet current health and safety standards
  • Renovate outdated classrooms, science labs and job training facilities
  • Upgrade training facilities for law enforcement, fire science and emergency services
  • Replace leaky roofs and 30-year-old temporary classrooms
  • Upgrade electrical systems for safety and improved access to technology
  • Add academic and job training classrooms and instructional support space
  • Replace deteriorated plumbing and sewer systems
  • Upgrade inefficient energy, heating and ventilation systems

All funds raised by Measure E will stay in our community to benefit our students. Passage of Measure E will qualify our colleges for state matching funds when they become available.

Independent audits will be conducted annually and an independent Citizens Oversight Committee will monitor all expenditures to ensure funds are spent properly.

Measure E is supported by educators, business and community leaders, students, parents and senior citizens throughout our community.

Please vote YES on Measure E.

/s/ Elaine Alquist, State Assemblywoman

/s/ Michael E. Fox, Sr., Community/Business Leader

/s/ Joan Sarlo, Founding Faculty Member - West Valley College

/s/ William H. Cilker, Senior Citizen

/s/ Chris C. Constantin, Former Student/Trustee

Rebuttal to Arguments For
This ballot statement is intentionally deceptive and substantially false.

It never mentions the amount of the bonds!

They don't want you to know Measure E will cost you 715 Million dollars in new taxes but generate only 248 Million for West Valley-Mission Community College District. This is beyond greed; it's obscene.

Their ballot statement does not include the typical hardship exemption for seniors on fixed incomes and other low income families.

The Citizen Oversight Committee would be appointed by the West Valley-Mission Community College District. How could it be unbiased or impartial?

Their statement suggests almost all the funds are for renovation and repair. Untrue! Actually, over 190 Million dollars will be used for repaying existing debt, new construction, an unspecified slush fund for "student support", and additional athletic facilities (e.g., concession stands, light standards, amplified sound systems).

They claim "outstanding educational opportunities." Untrue! District academic performance has been deteriorating: Less than 4% of the West Valley-Mission Community College District's 26,000 students earn degrees each year. (District Report 12-13-01). Did you know that 60% of those students live outside our District?

Proposed projects were selected by marketing research surveys, not based on educational need.

  • The West Valley-Mission Community College District's annual budget is over $100 million per year.
  • Plus several million more per year in extra local funding.
  • They already spend half their budget outside the classroom!

State matching funds are a dream, not a certainty. Without them, this measure will produce more unfinished projects and require more future taxes.

Vote "NO" on Measure E.

/s/ Victor Monia, Former Trustee, West Valley-Mission Comm. College District

/s/ Adrienne Loo, Psychology Graduate Student, West San Jose Voter

/s/ Sandra Todd, Los Gatos Voter & Mother of West Valley College Graduate

/s/ Charles Butterfield, Campbell Voter

/s/ Ann Waltonsmith, Saratoga City Councilperson (For idenfication purpose only)

Do not be fooled. This is not a $268,000,000 bond measure. This measure will cost residents $715,000,000 in extra taxes! (Source The West Valley-Mission Community College District bonds underwriter) Many families will pay $4,000 to $10,000 or more in new taxes.

The real issue is District mismanagement of money from tuition, fees, state allocations and rents:

  • Three years ago, the West Valley - Mission Community College District "lost" $3,000,000. District officials believe it was an accounting error, but aren't certain.
  • The District Foundation's treasurer was prosecuted for embezzling Foundation funds.
  • The last two external audits revealed inadequate safeguards for handling cash accounts and lack of corrective action.
  • Unlike other community colleges, the West Valley - Mission Community College District receives over $3,200,000 per year from lease of surplus properties.
  • The last two years the State gave the District $7,000,000 to improve academic programs. Sadly, the District's academic performance has instead deteriorated. Total degrees and certificates granted have fallen 25% since 1997; the number of "transfer ready" students has decreased 25% and basic skills improvement (reading and math) has dropped 10% since 1997. (Source: The Community College Chancellor's Office reports).

This tax measure was approved at a "special" Board meeting with no advertising. Not one member of the public was in attendance - no public hearings
  • Even the Trustees never saw the project list until that night.
  • Most projects are "guesstimates" - no detailed cost analysis made available

With a parcel tax, the District would receive one dollar for each dollar of new taxes. Instead, these bonds cost residents three dollars for each dollar the District receives, and the repayment obligation for taxpayers is thirty-eight years!

Vote "NO" on this three quarter Billion dollar, new tax, bond measure. This is greed, not need. This District had not been fiscally responsible and its academic performance has been deteriorating. Send a clear message - Unjustified spending of public funds must stop!

/s/ Charles Butterfield, Campbell Voter

/s/ Leslye G. Fazio, West Valley Homeowners Assoc.

/s/ Victor Monia, Former Trustee - West Valley-Mission Community College

/s/ Scott Runde, President - Primavera Homeowners Assoc. of Santa Clara

/s/ D. N. Davis, Santa Clara Voter

Rebuttal to Arguments Against
Measure E opponents are deliberately misleading voters with inaccurate, untruthful statements.

Here are the facts:

West Valley College and Mission College need major repair, renovation and upgrading. Job training facilities are outdated and in some cases obsolete. Although well maintained, these educational facilities need updating to provide for ongoing educational needs of students who will transfer to four year colleges and citizens needing job training and career advancement courses.

The cost of this bond measure is small, about $14 per year per $100,000 of assessed valuation (not to be confused with market value). This is tax deductible.

State law requires a specific plan for use of these funds. Only repairs and construction essential to maintain quality educational programs are included. There are no frills, no expensive wish lists, no blank checks.

By law, no funds may be used to pay administrative salaries or benefits. Funds can only be used for facility improvements.

Passage of Measure E will qualify our community for state matching funds that would otherwise go to other community colleges in other parts of the state.

Passage of Measure E will ensure that our community colleges have the necessary facilities students need to face the challenges of a competitive job market and economy.

Measure E has earned the support of both Democratic and Republican leaders.

Nurses, police, firefighters, emergency medical workers, and those served by these professionals, are some of the many Santa Clara Valley residents who will benefit from improved community college classrooms and facilities.

Please vote yes.

/s/ Elaine Alquist, Assemblywoman

/s/ Michael E. Fox, Sr., Business & Community Leader

/s/ Joan Sarlo, Founding Faculty - West Valley College

/s/ William H. Cilker, Senior Citizen/Community Leader

/s/ Chris C. Constantin, Former Student/Trustee

Tax Rate Statement from the Chancellor
An election will be held in the West Valley-Mission Community College District (the "District") on March 5, 2002, for the purpose of submitting to the electors of the District the question of incurring a bonded indebtedness of the District in a principal amount not to exceed $268,653,300. If such bonds are authorized and sold, the principal thereof and interest thereon will be payable from the proceeds of tax levies made upon the taxable property in the District. The following information regarding tax rates is given to comply with Section 9401 of the California Elections Code. Such information is based upon the best estimates and projections presently available from official sources, upon experience with the District, and other demonstrable factors.

Based upon the foregoing and projections of the District's assessed valuation, and assuming the entire debt service will be paid through property taxation:
1. The best estimate of the tax rate that would be required to be levied to fund the bond issue during the first fiscal year after the sale of the first series of bonds based on estimated assessed valuations available at the time of filing of this statement is 1.407 cents per $100 of assessed valuation (or $14.07 per $100,000 of assessed valuation) for fiscal year 2002-03.

2. The best estimate of the tax rate that would be required to be levied to fund the bond issue during the first fiscal year after the sale of the last series of bonds based on estimated assessed valuations available at the time of filing of this statement is 1.407 cents per $100 of assessed valuation (or $14.07 per $100,000 of assessed valuation) for fiscal year 2008-09.

3. The best estimate of the highest tax rate that would be required to be levied to fund the bond issue, and an estimate of the years in which that rate will apply, based on estimated assessed valuations available at the time of the filing of this statement is 1.407 cents per $100 of assessed valuation (or $14.07 per $100,000 of assessed valuation) for fiscal years 2002-03 through 2008-09.

Attention of all voters is directed to the fact that the foregoing information is based upon projections and estimates only, which are not binding upon the District. The actual timing of bond sales and the amount of bonds sold at any given time will be governed by the needs of the District, the state of the bond market, and other factors. The actual interest rates on any bonds sold will depend upon market conditions and other factors at the time of sale. The actual assessed valuations in future years will depend upon the value of property within the District as determined in the assessment and equalization process. Therefore, the actual tax rates and the years in which such rates are applicable may vary from those presently estimated as stated above.

/s/ Linda G. Salter, Chancellor, West Valley-Mission Community College District

Full Text of Measure E
The following is the full proposition presented to the voters by the West Valley-Mission Community College District.

"To improve educational opportunities for local residents, shall West Valley-Mission Community College District issue $268,653,300 in bonds at legal interest rates to construct, acquire, repair and equip classrooms, libraries, science/computer labs, facilities/sites, upgrade technology, improve safety, lighting, electrical, energy conservation, ventilation/plumbing systems, appoint a Citizen's Oversight Committee to perform annual audits and ensure that no bond money is used for salaries, administrative expenses?"

The Board of Trustees of the West Valley-Mission Community College District has evaluated safety, class size reduction, and information technology needs in developing the scope of college facility projects to be funded as outlined in both the District's West Valley College Educational and Facilities Master Plan, dated February 16, 2001, and as shall be amended from time to time and the Mission College Educational and Facilities Master Plan, dated October 2, 2001, and as shall be amended from time to time, each on file for review at the Chancellor's Office:

PROJECTS

Mission College

  • Main Building repair, renovation and refurnishing for improved instruction, including new science labs, computer labs, and safety upgrades
  • Repair, renovation and upgrade existing classrooms
  • Replace aging portable classrooms with permanent classrooms
  • Construct and furnish a new classroom/instructional facility
  • Upgrade or construct job training classrooms
  • Repair deteriorating roofs
  • Upgrades to electrical, plumbing, mechanical, heating, ventilation, energy conservation, fire safety and security systems
  • Americans with Disabilities Act required improvements
  • Seismic and structural improvements to existing buildings
  • Safety upgrades to road and walkways
  • Upgrade technology infrastructure
  • Purchase multimedia and other equipment for the Learning Resource Center/Library
  • Purchase safety, ergonomic and instructional equipment for classrooms and work spaces, such as ergonomic furniture and multimedia equipment
  • Repair and renovate student support services building
  • Construct warehouse facilities for equipment and storage
  • Reduce outstanding debt for High Technology Campus Center
  • Construct institutional support facilities

West Valley College
  • Upgrade and expand the math and science instructional facilities
  • Repair and renovate Administration of Justice (law enforcement) instructional facilities
  • Construct and furnish technology center
  • Repair, renovate and upgrade existing classrooms
  • Construct new classrooms
  • Replace aging portable classrooms with permanent classrooms
  • Upgrade or construct job training classrooms
  • Repair deteriorating roofs
  • Upgrade to electrical, plumbing, mechanical, heating, ventilation, energy conservation, fire safety, and security systems
  • Americans with Disabilities Act required improvements
  • Seismic and structural improvements to existing buildings
  • Safety upgrades to roads and walkways
  • Renovate, modernize, complete and equip athletic facitilites at West Valley College
  • Replace portable Child Development Center facilities with permanent facilities
  • Upgrade the central plant for heating, ventilation and air conditioning
  • Upgrade and expand the Learning Resource Center/Library
  • Upgrade technology infrastructure
  • Renovate faculty workrooms and offices
  • Purchase safety, ergonomic and instructional equipment for classrooms and work spaces, such as ergonomic furniture and multimedia equipment.
  • Repair, renovate and expand Student Support Center facilities
  • Purchase temporary classrooms to accommodate construction
  • Reduce debt for information technology systems, a telephone system and portable facilities for police services, information technology services and general services department.
  • Construct institutional support facilities

The details of each of the above-mentioned projects are set forth in each of the Educational and Facilities Master Plans referenced above. The allocation of bond money may be affected by the District's receipt of State matching funds and final costs of each project. The budget for each project may be affected by factors beyond the District's control. The timing of projects will be established by the Board of Trustees after review by the Citizen Oversight Committee.


Santa Clara Home Page || Statewide Links || About Smart Voter || Feedback
Created: April 19, 2002 10:58 PDT
Smart Voter <http://www.smartvoter.org/>
Copyright © League of Women Voters of California Education Fund   http://ca.lwv.org
The League of Women Voters neither supports nor opposes candidates for public office or political parties.